THE PARAGRAPHS OF THE DAY

Ken Berwitz


Today\’s paragraphs come to us from Michelle Alexander, writing for The Nation. The title of her piece?  “Why Hillary Clinton Doesn\’t Deserve the Black Vote”

And if there is room for any more nails on the coffin waiting for Hillary Clinton\’s presidential hopes, this is going to contribute a few.

Read this and see why:

Black voters have been remarkably loyal to the Clintons formore than 25 years. It\’s true that we eventually lined up behind Barack Obamain 2008, but it\’s a measure of the Clinton allure that Hillary led Obama amongblack voters until he started winning caucuses and primaries. Now Hillary isrunning again. This time she\’s facing a democratic socialist who promises apolitical revolution that will bring universal healthcare, a living wage, anend to rampant Wall Street greed, and the dismantling of the vast prisonstate-many of the same goals that Martin Luther King Jr. championed at the endof his life. Even so, black folks are sticking with the Clinton brand.

What have theClintons done to earn such devotion? Did they take extreme political risks todefend the rights of African Americans? Did they courageously stand up toright-wing demagoguery about black communities? Did they help usher in a newera of hope and prosperity for neighborhoods devastated by deindustrialization,globalization, and the disappearance of work?

No. Quite theopposite.

When Bill Clinton ran for president in 1992, urban blackcommunities across America were suffering from economic collapse. Hundreds ofthousands of manufacturing jobs had vanished as factories moved overseas in searchof cheaper labor, a new plantation. Globalization and deindustrializationaffected workers of all colors but hit African Americans particularly hard.Unemployment rates among young black men had quadrupled as the rate ofindustrial employment plummeted. Crime rates spiked in inner-city communitiesthat had been dependent on factory jobs, while hopelessness, despair, and crackaddiction swept neighborhoods that had once been solidly working-class.Millions of black folks-many of whom had fled Jim Crow segregation in the Southwith the hope of obtaining decent work in Northern factories-were suddenlytrapped in racially segregated, jobless ghettos.

On the campaigntrail, Bill Clinton made the economy his top priority and argued persuasivelythat conservatives were using race to divide the nation and divert attentionfrom the failed economy. In practice, however, he capitulated entirely to theright-wing backlash against the civil-rights movement and embraced formerpresident Ronald Reagan\’s agenda on race, crime, welfare, and taxes-ultimatelydoing more harm to black communities than Reagan ever did.

Michelle Alexander is an accomplished writer who teaches law at Ohio State University.  She is well known and well respected. 
 
You may or may not agree with Ms. Alexander\’s points.  You may or may not think her dump-job on Hillary Clinton is fair.  But, regardless, you can bet that Bernie Sanders and his people are going to be using her words to persuade Black voters that they have no friend in either Hillary or Hubby Bubba.  If I were him, I would do the same thing.

Will it turn a lot of Black voters against the Clintons?  Probably not, given the extended love affair Black America has had with them.  

But you can bet it will turn some voters, not all of them Black either.  And it will make some of her supporters less enthusiastic about showing up on election day.  These factors can be the difference between a decisive victory and a tight race that shows vulnerability. They can even change a win into a loss.  Both prospects are devastating to the Clinton candidacy.

Michelle Alexander wins Paragraphs Of The Day honors for bringing home the reasons this might happen so well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *